| Frequently Asked Questions
What size hybrid drive should I buy?
1 KW of electric power can replace 3 or 4 horsepower of diesel
power. Size and pitch or propellor, type of packing gland or
dripless gland, gearbox ratio all affect the efficiency of an electric
drive. Diesels are rated at peak horsepower at peak rpm
which is rarely achieved on a boat. Diesels also contend
with two very inefficient water pumps, inefficient alterators and belt
losses. Considering 1 KW = .746 h.p., it becomes
obvious just how well suited electric propulsion is for boats.
Do I need an all electric boat or a diesel
electric hybrid?
As a boat approaches boat speed, the power required increases
exponentially. If you want to cruise at boat speed for
extended periods of time you will need a hybrid system with a diesel
generator. If you are a daysailer, and you are content
to travel at 75% of boat speed, then an all electric boat is right for
you.
How long will my batteries last?
How long batteries last depends on two major factors, boat speed and
battery size. Since power increases exponentially as boat
speed approaches hull speed, it is adviseable to travel at less than
full boat speed. A typical 30 foot boat draws 3 KW at 4
knots but over 6 KW at 6 knots. Not only does it
require exponentially more power to travel at full boat speed, batteries
become less efficient at higher current consumption.
Battery powered electric boats are not designed to travel at full boat
speed for long periods of time. It is easier to think
of it this way, if your
Not all batteries discharge the same amount. AGM and Gel
Batteries can be discharged by 50%. We recommend Odyssey
Batteries which can be discharged up to 80%. Odyssey
batteries use Pure Lead, Thin Plate design and are rated at 400 cycles
at 80 % discharge.
To calculate range, first convert amp hour ratings to kilowatt hour
ratings. But remember, amp hour ratings are dependent on
discharge time. Odyssey Batteries 2 hour rate is 71 percent
of their 20 hour rate. The PC 1800 Odyssey Battery has
a 20 hour amp hour rating of 214 amp hours, and a 2 hour rating of 153
amp hours. If we use the 2 hour rating, only 80 percent is
useable or 122 amp hours. If we multiply 122 amp hours x the
average voltage of 12.2 volts we get the 2 hour kilowatt rating of 1.5
KWH. Multiply by 4 and you have 6 KWH's in 4 PC
1800's. The two hour range at 3 KW / 4 knots would be
2 hours or 8 nautical miles.
The PC 1800 Odyssey Battery has a 1 hour rating of 136 amp
hours. Only 80 percent is useable or 108 amp hours.
If we multiply 108 amp hours x the average voltage of 12.2 volts we get
the 1 hour kilowatt rating of 1.3 KWH. Multiply by 4
and you have a one hour rating of 5.3 KWH's in 4 PC 1800's.
The one hour range at 6 KW at 6 Knots would be 53 minutes or 5.3
nautical miles.
How do I make my batteries last even longer?
The ultimate point of sail for an electric sailboat is motor sailing.
When the wind is very slight your sails luff. It takes a
very small amount of energy, 1 KW, to move the boat along at 2
knots. There is almost always 1 or 2 knots of wind out
there, so now you have 3 or 4 knots of wind and you are moving along at
2 or 3 knots.
The 8 hour rate of the PC 1800 is 186 amp hours of which 150 amp
hours is available multiply by 12.2 volts to get 1.8 KWH multiply by 4
(for 48 volts) = 7.3 KWH At 1 KW at 3
knots your light air range is 7.3 hours or 22 nautical miles.
What does efficiency have to do with
designing a powerful hybrid drive?
The most important factor regarding an electric drive installation is
the efficiency of the components. Overall efficiency of the system is
calculated by multiplying the individual efficiency of each of the
components. Our system utilizes a Mars brushless, permanent magnet
motor (93% efficient), a Sevcon controller (93% efficient) and a Edison
gearbox (97% efficient). System efficiency is .93 x .93 x .97 or 83%
efficient. What this means is that 17% of the power that is consumed
generates heat. So when the motor is drawing 4.7 KW, 17% of that or
800 watts is being converted into heat.
Why is heat a problem with electric drives?
Electricity does not like heat, all conductors become less conductive
when they are hotter. If the engine room is unable to dissipate 800
watts of heat in this example, the system will overheat. When the
system overheats, the controller either reduces power output or shuts it
off completely, something you do not want to happen. When you select
efficient components you create less heat. All systems create heat
because nothing is 100 percent efficient. Dissipating the heat ensures
that the system stays cooler. Heat sinks, fans, adequate ventilation
and water cooling are several ways the heat can be dissipated.
What's the difference between different types
of electric motors?
A DC motor accepts direct current, while an AC motor accepts
alternating current. Here's the interesting part though - all
electric motors are AC motors. DC motors convert DC to AC
mechanically through the armature and brushes. The Mars brushless
motor is a 3 phase AC motor. The controller is where the DC is changed
into AC. AC motors are desireable because they do not require
brushes. Brushes require maintenance and also spark so are not
ignition proof.
A motor shaft turns because the magnet that is attached to the shaft
( the rotor), is inside a moving magnetic field created by the
stator. At least one of these two magnets must be an
electromagnet. Most motors use two electromagnets. An electromagnet
is a created by wrapping a wire around a metallic object and then
applying electrical power to that wire. Effectively this is a short
circuit which creates heat. Permanent magnet motor employ
rare earth permanent magnets in their rotors, thus eliminating the need for the
second electromagnet, thus increasing efficiency.
Brushless, Permanent Magnet motors are the most efficient motors
available today.
What does the controller do?
The Sevcon Permanent Magnet AC controller which we use for the Mars
motor is a variable frequency inverter which converts DC power into 3
phase AC power. Controllers are programmable for maximum
current, how quickly they can accelerate and regenerative
characteristics.
What voltage system is the best for my boat?
Higher voltage is desirable because it requires less current, however
higher voltage requires more safety equipment. You have DC and AC voltages on a
boat. DC voltage is considered dangerous over 50 volts while AC
voltage is commonly employed and considered safe up to 120 volts. Our
electric drives are DC between the batteries and the controller and then
AC between the controller and the motor.
With respect to the design, anything in excess of 50 volts must be
handled carefully and fully insulated with a secondary sheath enclosing
the high voltage DC cables. My recommendation is to pick a voltage
that allows you to not exceed 100 amps in current. If you need 4.8KW,
use a 48 volt system. If you need 7.2 KW, use a 72 volt system.
How do I effectively manage the amperage within
the system?
Amperage creates heat. Lower voltage systems require higher
amperage to create the same power. Remember that Power is Voltage
multiplied by Amperage. Reducing amperage is always desireable.
However lower voltage is safer. You are going to have to deal with
amperage and minimize its effects on the system. Use high quality,
large cables for your main power cables. 2/0 cables have an ampacity of 330 amps so are well within
their designed use. Larger cable has less voltage drop so the engine
uses a higher voltage. This is especially important when the electric
engine is functioning at full power.
Why is Gear Ratio so important?
Electric motors draw current
proportionately to their load. Since the load increases
exponentially to rpm, fine tuned gearing has tremendous benefits in
reliability and maximum power created.
The first time an electric motor is
installed it needs to be run at full throttle. If it develops less
current than what it is rated for then choose a lower number in the
gear ratio.( closer to 1.25: 1) If it develops more current than
what its rated for then choose a higher number in the gear ratio.
(closer to 5:1) The closer you can get to its continuous
operating current at that gear ratio, the more efficient and reliable the
electric motor will be.
Above the Waterline has solved the gear
ratio problem associated with electric drive installations by using
Browning Gearboxes. We have 10 different gear ratios between
1.25:1 and 5:1. We offer an exchange program for our customers to
allow them to optimize to their particular sailboat. All
propellors are different and all packing glands have different
resistances so this service is very important. No other electric
drive manufacturer offers this service as part of the purchase.
If the motor does not reach its peak
operating current it will not develop its peak power.
If the motor exceeds its peak power it
will cost efficiency. However, it may be desireable to be able to
develop more than its peak continuous power. If it is geared to
develop more than its peak power, beware of the intermittent
rating. For instance, Sevcon's controller is capable of producing
95 amps at 48 volts continuously, however it is capable of producing
up to 200 amps for up to 2 minutes. If pressed to exceed the
time limit, either the controller will overheat or a time out
circuit is activated, then the controller either substantially
reduces power or shuts off completely.
Gearing it to be able to develop the
intermittent rating allows incredible acceleration and
deceleration. One test showed achieving full boat speed within
two boat lengths when geared in this fashion. We recommend if a
customer wants to gear their boat this way that they install an
ammeter with a warning of exceeding the continous ratings.
What can I expect of my
electric drive when it's completed?
Properly installed, an electric motor
can give years of reliable service, all at the touch of a switch.
Be careful and play close attention to the details of the
installation for safety and efficiency. Higher efficiency
translates into higher power and longer range. Use quality
components and don't rush the installation. Electricity is
powerful and when harnessed safely can be the most enjoyable means
of transportation known to man.
|